to much vigor and no hp when using full perrys
Why in the world would you need HP for a duel set? Especially for a melee weapon set, you have almost 6 k HP (11k for a soldier) only from strength and perry's set (with felt hat). Why would you reduce a very important skill for HP? You have enough HP, you don't need more. But you need vigor. First of all, you are a complete noob if you use full perry clothes, second of all, you need vigor. Perry is good in combinations. You can use perry in combination with josephina's for vigor aiming dodging appearance. You can use it in combination with tailor items for full appearance aiming/doding mode. Losing vigor would minimize the effectiveness of the set in combinations, especially versus opponents playing with mclaughlin / highlander or other combinations with t/r tactics. You clearly don't know much about duel, stop proposing stupid things for the sake of "feedback". And bring arguments next time.
Al35ul listened to someone who propose speed for the useless Brooks set. Speed for a duel set...
First of all, you change your set between duels, second of all, you have to change your set in order to change locations, so you'll use the speed set anyway. And duellers (like the one who made that proposal, who by the way, do not duel and have no idea about duel) don't need speed on sets, because they can duel everyone without moving. Nowadays horses have enough speed. The speed is completely useless for everyone, including duelists.
What's more, you have to change the set for opponents anyway, to adjust certain items at least, so it didn't use that speed on items anyway. Not to mention that the set is completely useless, you don't need reflex and appearance, that set is a huge mistake. But this happens when you listen to the most stupid proposals without arguments and logic, but those that make sense and are well supported are ignored.
When i proposed a reflex set, we were back in the vaquero's days, and i said we need a reflex set with AIMING, not with appearance.