• Howdy partner! You seem new here. Why don't you make an account and join the discussion? You can register here.
    Already have one? Then you login here!
  • Welcome to the saloon, Guest!
    This is the place where you can discuss about anything you want! Well, almost.
    Try to not break any of the Rules whenever you post otherwise the sheriff might lock you down!

Valentine's Day Event 2024 Sets - Feedback

Loki

Loki

The West Team
Howdy Cowgirls & Cowboys,

as every year, during the Valentine's Day Event, you will have a chance to win two sets. :lovetw:
You, the Beta Community, are very important to us, and we always look forward to your feedback.

Please check the sets below and let us know your opinion (how and what you would change). :up:

Item​
Bonus per level​
Bonus at level 150​
Bonus at level 200​
Hat+0.035 Strength (per level)
+0.035 Charisma (per level)
+0.50 0.45 Toughness (per level)
+0.30 Health Points (per level)
+0.45 Aiming (per level)		+6 Strength
+6 Charisma
+75 68 Toughness
+45 Health Points
+68 Aiming		+7 Strength
+7 Charisma
+100 90 Toughness
+60 Health Points
+90 Aiming
Neck+0.045 Strength (per level)
+0.035 Charisma (per level)
+0.35 Toughness (per level)
+0.45 Aiming (per level)
+0.50 0.40 Tactics (per level)
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles		+7 Strength
+6 Charisma
+53 Toughness
+68 Aiming
+75 60 Tactics
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles		+9 Strength
+7 Charisma
+70 Toughness
+90 Aiming
+100 80 Tactics
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles
Body+0.065 Strength (per level)
+0.035 Mobility (per level)
+0.045 Charisma (per level)
+0.55 Toughness (per level)
+0.40 Reflex (per level)
+0.55 Aiming (per level)
+0.30 0.25 Tactics (per level)
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles		+10 Strength
+6 Mobility
+7 Charisma
+83 Toughness
+60 Reflex
+83 Aiming
+45 38 Tactics
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles		+13 Strength
+7 Mobility
+9 Charisma
+110 Toughness
+80 Reflex
+110 Aiming
+60 50 Tactics
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles
Belt+0.055 Strength (per level)
+0.035 Charisma (per level)
+0.55 Toughness (per level)
+0.35 0.30 Health Points (per level)
+0.45 Aiming (per level)
+0.25 Tactics (per level)
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles		+9 Strength
+6 Charisma
+83 Toughness
+53 45 Health Points
+68 Aiming
+38 Tactics
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles		+11 Strength
+7 Charisma
+110 Toughness
+70 60 Health Points
+90 Aiming
+50 Tactics
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles
Pants+0.065 Strength (per level)
+0.035 Mobility (per level)
+0.035 Charisma (per level)
+0.45 0.40 Toughness (per level)
+0.55 Reflex (per level)
+0.50 Aiming (per level)
+0.30 Tactics (per level)
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles		+10 Strength
+6 Mobility
+6 Charisma
+68 60 Toughness
+83 Reflex
+75 Aiming
+45 Tactics
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles		+13 Strength
+7 Mobility
+7 Charisma
+90 80 Toughness
+110 Reflex
+100 Aiming
+60 Tactics
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles
Shoes+0.045 Strength (per level)
+0.025 Mobility (per level)
+0.025 Charisma (per level)
+0.45 Toughness (per level)
+0.55 0.50 Aiming (per level)
+0.45 Tactics (per level)		+7 Strength
+4 Mobility
+4 Charisma
+68 Toughness
+83 75 Aiming
+68 Tactics		+9 Strength
+5 Mobility
+5 Charisma
+90 Toughness
+110 100 Aiming
+90 Tactics
Clothes set bonus (for all items)+0.11 Strength (per level)
+0.11 Mobility (per level)
+0.11 Charisma (per level)
+1.00 Toughness (per level)
+0.70 Health Points (per level)
+1.00 Aiming (per level)
+0.40 Tactics (per level)
+50% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles		+17 Strength
+17 Mobility
+17 Charisma
+150 Toughness
+105 Health Points
+150 Aiming
+60 Tactics
+50% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles		+22 Strength
+22 Mobility
+22 Charisma
+200 Toughness
+140 Health Points
+200 Aiming
+80 Tactics
+50% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles

Item​
Bonus per level​
Bonus at level 150​
Bonus at level 200​
Hat+0.035 Strength (per level)
+0.035 Mobility (per level)
+0.45 Vigor (per level)
+0.50 Stamina (per level)
+0.45 Horseback Riding (per level)
+10 labor points		+6 Strength
+6 Mobility
+68 Vigor
+75 Stamina
+68 Horseback Riding
+10 labor points		+7 Strength
+7 Mobility
+90 Vigor
+100 Stamina
+90 Horseback Riding
+10 labor points
Neck+0.035 Mobility (per level)
+0.035 Dexterity (per level)
+0.50 Swimming (per level)
+0.45 Setting Traps (per level)
+0.50 Fine Motor Skills (per level)
+10 labor points		+6 Mobility
+6 Dexterity
+75 Swimming
+68 Setting Traps
+75 Fine Motor Skills
+10 labor points		+7 Mobility
+7 Dexterity
+100 Swimming
+90 Setting Traps
+100 Fine Motor Skills
+10 labor points
Body+0.045 Mobility (per level)
+0.045 Dexterity (per level)
+0.045 Charisma (per level)
+0.55 Setting Traps (per level)
+0.55 Fine Motor Skills (per level)
+0.55 Trading (per level)
+0.55 Tactics (per level)
+10 labor points		+7 Mobility
+7 Dexterity
+7 Charisma
+83 Setting Traps
+83 Fine Motor Skills
+83 Trading
+83 Tactics
+10 labor points		+9 Mobility
+9 Dexterity
+9 Charisma
+110 Setting Traps
+110 Fine Motor Skills
+110 Trading
+110 Tactics
+10 labor points
Belt+0.045 Mobility (per level)
+0.045 Dexterity (per level)
+0.045 Charisma (per level)
+0.55 Setting Traps (per level)
+0.55 Trading (per level)
+0.55 Tactics (per level)
+10 labor points		+7 Mobility
+7 Dexterity
+7 Charisma
+83 Setting Traps
+83 Trading
+83 Tactics
+10 labor points		+9 Mobility
+9 Dexterity
+9 Charisma
+110 Setting Traps
+110 Trading
+110 Tactics
+10 labor points
Pants+0.045 Strength (per level)
+0.045 Mobility (per level)
+0.045 Dexterity (per level)
+0.55 Vigor (per level)
+0.55 Stamina (per level)
+0.55 Horseback Riding (per level)
+0.55 Swimming (per level)
+10 labor points		+7 Strength
+7 Mobility
+7 Dexterity
+83 Vigor
+83 Stamina
+83 Horseback Riding
+83 Swimming
+10 labor points		+9 Strength
+9 Mobility
+9 Dexterity
+110 Vigor
+110 Stamina
+110 Horseback Riding
+110 Swimming
+10 labor points
Shoes+0.045 Strength (per level)
+0.045 Mobility (per level)
+0.045 Dexterity (per level)
+0.55 Horseback Riding (per level)
+0.55 Swimming (per level)
+0.55 Setting Traps (per level)
+10 labor points		+7 Strength
+7 Mobility
+7 Dexterity
+83 Horseback Riding
+83 Swimming
+83 Setting Traps
+10 labor points		+9 Strength
+9 Mobility
+9 Dexterity
+110 Horseback Riding
+110 Swimming
+110 Setting Traps
+10 labor points
Clothes set bonus (for all items)+0.11 Strength (per level)
+0.11 Mobility (per level)
+0.11 Dexterity (per level)
+0.11 Charisma (per level)
+1.10 Vigor (per level)
+1.10 Stamina (per level)
+1.10 Horseback Riding (per level)
+1.10 Swimming (per level)
+1.10 Setting Traps (per level)
+1.10 Fine Motor Skills (per level)
+1.10 Trading (per level)
+1.10 Tactics (per level)
+90% 60% Improved product drop chance
+50% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles
+100 labor points		+17 Strength
+17 Mobility
+17 Dexterity
+17 Charisma
+165 Vigor
+165 Stamina
+165 Horseback Riding
+165 Swimming
+165 Setting Traps
+165 Fine Motor Skills
+165 Trading
+165 Tactics
+90% 60% Improved product drop chance
+50% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles
+100 labor points		+22 Strength
+22 Mobility
+22 Dexterity
+22 Charisma
+220 Vigor
+220 Stamina
+220 Horseback Riding
+220 Swimming
+220 Setting Traps
+220 Fine Motor Skills
+220 Trading
+220 Tactics
+90% 60% Improved product drop chance
+50% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles
+100 labor points

ItemBonus per levelBonus at level 150Bonus at level 150
Animal+250% Speed
+0.055 Strength (per level)
+0.055 Mobility (per level)
+0.45 Vigor (per level)
+0.45 Stamina (per level)
+0.55 Horseback Riding (per level)
+15 labor points
+25% Speed		+250% Speed
+9 Strength
+9 Mobility
+68 Vigor
+68 Stamina
+83 Horseback Riding
+15 labor points
+25% Speed		+250% Speed
+12 Strength
+12 Mobility
+90 Vigor
+90 Stamina
+110 Horseback Riding
+15 labor points
+25% Speed
Yield+0.045 Dexterity (per level)
+0.045 Charisma (per level)
+0.55 Setting Traps (per level)
+0.45 Fine Motor Skills (per level)
+0.45 Tactics (per level)
+15 labor points		+7 Dexterity
+7 Charisma
+83 Setting Traps
+68 Fine Motor Skills
+68 Tactics
+15 labor points		+9 Dexterity
+9 Charisma
+110 Setting Traps
+90 Fine Motor Skills
+90 Tactics
+15 labor points
Animal + yield set bonus+0.055 Strength (per level)
+0.055 Mobility (per level)
+0.055 Dexterity (per level)
+0.055 Charisma (per level)
+0.55 Vigor (per level)
+0.55 Horseback Riding (per level)
+0.55 Fine Motor Skills (per level)
+0.55 Tactics (per level)
+40% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles
+35% Improved product drop chance
+80 labor points		+9 Strength
+9 Mobility
+9 Dexterity
+9 Charisma
+83 Vigor
+83 Horseback Riding
+83 Fine Motor Skills
+83 Tactics
+40% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles
+35% Improved product drop chance
+80 labor points		+12 Strength
+12 Mobility
+12 Dexterity
+12 Charisma
+110 Vigor
+110 Horseback Riding
+110 Fine Motor Skills
+110 Tactics
+40% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles
+35% Improved product drop chance
+80 labor points

ItemBonus per levelBonus at level 150Bonus at level 200
MeleeDamage 15 - 25
+1.2 Damage (per Level)
+0.045 Strength (per level)
+0.045 Mobility (per level)
+0.55 Vigor (per level)
+0.55 Stamina (per level)
+0.55 Swimming (per level)
+15 labor points		Damage 15 - 25
+180 Damage
+7 Strength
+7 Mobility
+83 Vigor
+83 Stamina
+83 Swimming
+15 labor points		Damage 15 - 25
+240 Damage
+9 Strength
+9 Mobility
+110 Vigor
+110 Stamina
+110 Swimming
+15 labor points
RangeDamage 15 - 25
+1.2 Damage (per Level)
+0.045 Dexterity (per level)
+0.045 Charisma (per level)
+0.55 Shooting (per level)
+0.55 Setting Traps (per level)
+0.55 Trading (per level)
+15 labor points		Damage 15 - 25
+180 Damage
+7 Dexterity
+7 Charisma
+83 Shooting
+83 Setting Traps
+83 Trading
+15 labor points		Damage 15 - 25
+240 Damage
+9 Dexterity
+9 Charisma
+110 Shooting
+110 Setting Traps
+110 Trading
+15 labor points
FortDamage 20 - 45
+2.2 Damage (per Level)
+0.055 Strength (per level)
+0.055 Mobility (per level)
+0.055 Dexterity (per level)
+0.055 Charisma (per level)
+0.55 Setting Traps (per level)
+0.55 Trading (per level)
+0.55 Tactics (per level)
+15 labor points		Damage 20 - 45
+330 Damage
+9 Strength
+9 Mobility
+9 Dexterity
+9 Charisma
+83 Setting Traps
+83 Trading
+83 Tactics
+15 labor points		Damage 20 - 45
+440 Damage
+11 Strength
+11 Mobility
+11 Dexterity
+11 Charisma
+110 Setting Traps
+110 Trading
+110 Tactics
+15 labor points
Weapon set bonus+0.055 Strength (per level)
+0.055 Mobility (per level)
+0.055 Dexterity (per level)
+0.055 Charisma (per level)
+0.55 Stamina (per level)
+0.55 Swimming (per level)
+0.55 Setting Traps (per level)
+0.55 Trading (per level)
+40% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles
+35% Improved product drop chance
+80 labor points		+9 Strength
+9 Mobility
+9 Dexterity
+9 Charisma
+83 Stamina
+83 Swimming
+83 Setting Traps
+83 Trading
+40% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles
+35% Improved product drop chance
+80 labor points		+11 Strength
+11 Mobility
+11 Dexterity
+11 Charisma
+110 Stamina
+110 Swimming
+110 Setting Traps
+110 Trading
+40% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles
+35% Improved product drop chance
+80 labor points


We are looking forward to see your feedback!

Yours sincerely,
Loki​
Community Manager
 
Emma Swan

Emma Swan

Corporal
Free set looks to be appropriate for free set, not extreme like Black heart.
As for resistance set, I wouldnt add health to resistance sets just because how are you able to give a KO? Imagine soldier with this, high hp, bonus tactics, without any chance. Make those duels more duelable jesus. You cant add always HP to resistance and tactics sets.

I say remove health point and make this set for attack. When you see somebody attacking someone in Pearl, you have a high chance to win with Nate set. So make this set for attack against Papa and Owens. Of course you have to combine this set with other resistance items, but thats as always. Nate set would have been better without health bonus. Sometimes I think like these sets are made after 5 bacardi colas.... Resistance set is not only for defending, look at hunters set, at that time you could win against soldier with hugh tactics. Now its not strong enough anymore.

Thats what I would change. If you are worried by removing hp from this set, just remove it from nates set as well and you are good to go. Duels arent fun anymore after dueling sets with huge hp, like in polly you can have 16k like nothing. madhouse
 
Emma Swan

Emma Swan

Corporal
Isnt it maybe better to switch those sets as well? Free resistance with guns and horseride and your experience/drop rate set and buff it for exp/drop/Lpoints? So that we can upgrade it? Just thinking out loud....
 

Mia Corvere

Reservist
Emma Swan said:
Isnt it maybe better to switch those sets as well? Free resistance with guns and horseride and your experience/drop rate set and buff it for exp/drop/Lpoints? So that we can upgrade it? Just thinking out loud....
Click to expand...
you wouldn't get weapons or animal in that case, though
 
dublik

dublik

Lance Corporal
For free set, id increase the drop from 120% to at least 190% in total, remove trading and add Animal Instincts or Shooting and based on this adjustment, replace either vigor or stamina with animal instinct/shooting. Also buff all labor points by 5%.

In the first set, increase tactics in all items by 0,1 per level and the other skills by 0,05 per level
 

Brunofs

Reservist
It would be nice for dueslist set to be an offensive one with resistance, a gordan 2.0. Last year and a half it came out 3 defensive sets (polly, sara and oktober male). In my honest opinion, another defensive set with those stats wont bring much to the game.
 
Miss Florida

Miss Florida

Lance Corporal
For set 1, increase the tactics bonus to +1.0 and exp bonus +60%.

For set 2, increase the labor points bonus of full cloths to +150, full weapons to +100 and full animal set to +100. Increase the exp bonus of full cloths to +60% and consider adding +20% exp bonus to some part of clothing. Increase the drop rate of full cloths set to 120%.
 
Loki

Loki

The West Team
Update:
Loki said:
Item​
Bonus per level​
Bonus at level 150​
Bonus at level 200​
Hat+0.035 Strength (per level)
+0.035 Charisma (per level)
+0.50 0.45 Toughness (per level)
+0.30 Health Points (per level)
+0.45 Aiming (per level)		+6 Strength
+6 Charisma
+75 68 Toughness
+45 Health Points
+68 Aiming		+7 Strength
+7 Charisma
+100 90 Toughness
+60 Health Points
+90 Aiming
Neck+0.045 Strength (per level)
+0.035 Charisma (per level)
+0.35 Toughness (per level)
+0.45 Aiming (per level)
+0.50 0.40 Tactics (per level)
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles		+7 Strength
+6 Charisma
+53 Toughness
+68 Aiming
+75 60 Tactics
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles		+9 Strength
+7 Charisma
+70 Toughness
+90 Aiming
+100 80 Tactics
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles
Body+0.065 Strength (per level)
+0.035 Mobility (per level)
+0.045 Charisma (per level)
+0.55 Toughness (per level)
+0.40 Reflex (per level)
+0.55 Aiming (per level)
+0.30 0.25 Tactics (per level)
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles		+10 Strength
+6 Mobility
+7 Charisma
+83 Toughness
+60 Reflex
+83 Aiming
+45 38 Tactics
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles		+13 Strength
+7 Mobility
+9 Charisma
+110 Toughness
+80 Reflex
+110 Aiming
+60 50 Tactics
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles
Belt+0.055 Strength (per level)
+0.035 Charisma (per level)
+0.55 Toughness (per level)
+0.35 0.30 Health Points (per level)
+0.45 Aiming (per level)
+0.25 Tactics (per level)
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles		+9 Strength
+6 Charisma
+83 Toughness
+53 45 Health Points
+68 Aiming
+38 Tactics
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles		+11 Strength
+7 Charisma
+110 Toughness
+70 60 Health Points
+90 Aiming
+50 Tactics
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles
Pants+0.065 Strength (per level)
+0.035 Mobility (per level)
+0.035 Charisma (per level)
+0.45 0.40 Toughness (per level)
+0.55 Reflex (per level)
+0.50 Aiming (per level)
+0.30 Tactics (per level)
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles		+10 Strength
+6 Mobility
+6 Charisma
+68 60 Toughness
+83 Reflex
+75 Aiming
+45 Tactics
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles		+13 Strength
+7 Mobility
+7 Charisma
+90 80 Toughness
+110 Reflex
+100 Aiming
+60 Tactics
+5% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles
Shoes+0.045 Strength (per level)
+0.025 Mobility (per level)
+0.025 Charisma (per level)
+0.45 Toughness (per level)
+0.55 0.50 Aiming (per level)
+0.45 Tactics (per level)		+7 Strength
+4 Mobility
+4 Charisma
+68 Toughness
+83 75 Aiming
+68 Tactics		+9 Strength
+5 Mobility
+5 Charisma
+90 Toughness
+110 100 Aiming
+90 Tactics

Item​
Bonus per level​
Bonus at level 150​
Bonus at level 200​
Clothes set bonus (for all items)+0.11 Strength (per level)
+0.11 Mobility (per level)
+0.11 Dexterity (per level)
+0.11 Charisma (per level)
+1.10 Vigor (per level)
+1.10 Stamina (per level)
+1.10 Horseback Riding (per level)
+1.10 Swimming (per level)
+1.10 Setting Traps (per level)
+1.10 Fine Motor Skills (per level)
+1.10 Trading (per level)
+1.10 Tactics (per level)
+90% 60% Improved product drop chance
+50% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles
+100 labor points		+17 Strength
+17 Mobility
+17 Dexterity
+17 Charisma
+165 Vigor
+165 Stamina
+165 Horseback Riding
+165 Swimming
+165 Setting Traps
+165 Fine Motor Skills
+165 Trading
+165 Tactics
+90% 60% Improved product drop chance
+50% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles
+100 labor points		+22 Strength
+22 Mobility
+22 Dexterity
+22 Charisma
+220 Vigor
+220 Stamina
+220 Horseback Riding
+220 Swimming
+220 Setting Traps
+220 Fine Motor Skills
+220 Trading
+220 Tactics
+90% 60% Improved product drop chance
+50% Experience from jobs, duels and fort battles
+100 labor points
Click to expand...
 
Emma Swan

Emma Swan

Corporal
I would add 200% extra tactics and 500% to health point but only if you are solider so that duels are better ballanced. I mean soldiet is so underrated in duels it cant win even under attack of 10 duelers.

Alsoo, I would buff tactics, if soldier than you get 100% bonus to tactics, 200% if you have premium.

I think one can understand creators of these sets if you act a bit stupid lol :D
 
WhyN0t

WhyN0t

Master Sergeant
The problem with tactical sets is as follows. If they are balanced for soldiers, they will be very poor for other classes, if they are good for other classes, they will be OP for soldiers. You can't balance tactics sets as long as soldiers have an insane bonus. And they have double hp on top of that, to be sure they can't be KOed.
 
Emma Swan

Emma Swan

Corporal
WhyN0t said:
The problem with tactical sets is as follows. If they are balanced for soldiers, they will be very poor for other classes, if they are good for other classes, they will be OP for soldiers. You can't balance tactics sets as long as soldiers have an insane bonus. And they have double hp on top of that, to be sure they can't be KOed.
Click to expand...
Every person with at least 1/14 of brain knows that. Or at least should.

You dont need to think too hard for that. Soldier tactics HP and resistance together? :D If there is no tactic bonus then we can close an eye and act like its a bit good set. But I will never understand how are you trying to revive duels if you are doing this sht.... Its like release set for Duelers, HP, Hiding, Setting traps, Aiming, leaderships at its fullest and 2000 dodge lol :D I can only laugh at this brainwashed company.
 
BaggyBlue

BaggyBlue

Master Sergeant
I think it's a good quantum leap from InnoGame. :up:
You can never please anyone. No matter what you do! As it is often written. A soldier is strong.
 

vitamin2002

Private
Emma Swan said:
I would add 200% extra tactics and 500% to health point but only if you are solider so that duels are better ballanced. I mean soldiet is so underrated in duels it cant win even under attack of 10 duelers.

Alsoo, I would buff tactics, if soldier than you get 100% bonus to tactics, 200% if you have premium.

I think one can understand creators of these sets if you act a bit stupid lol :D
Click to expand...
U even dont know premium are 150% not 200 %
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top