• Howdy partner! You seem new here. Why don't you make an account and join the discussion? You can register here.
    Already have one? Then you login here!
  • Welcome to the saloon, Guest!
    This is the place where you can discuss about anything you want! Well, almost.
    Try to not break any of the Rules whenever you post otherwise the sheriff might lock you down!

Oktoberfest 2026 Sets - Feedback

@Loki @ChickenMcGuy
Where exactly did we request these changes? Please provide the link
It took you 6 pages to make the changes and you did what we didn't ask for. I thought you would do it by looking at our feedback, but we didn't ask for that
 
@Loki @ChickenMcGuy

Let me be brief:

Free set: clothes and pants with 0.43 repair and 0.45 leadership? It's worse than the hat.
It's a set that doesn't improve, it'll probably be worse than an Austin set. So why release it?
A FREE SET DOESN'T HAVE TO BE BAD, REMEMBER?

Set 1: Drop: 35% neck, 45% belt; 35% shoes (leave Deputy Chef at 50% alive and we have shirt and pants Xochi with 30%, so we need to drop neck and belt) - drop neck drop belt....drop neck drop belt.....drop neck drop belt....ok?
Luck: 35% head; 45% shirt; 35% pants.

Note: move the labor points to the bonus, making it 300 labor points in the bonus - very good.

Leave the bonus only luck and drop like the clothes, money and xp aren't in the clothes and it doesn't match. Let's do it right this time.

Make one weapon luck and another drop, THAT'S ALL.

Set 3: 0.25 tactics was very strange, why is that?
Dodging and tactics have to go hand in hand, separated they are useless.
 
Free set ,we dont need a new building set, austin has been only realized last year dont know why most of you crying about it already. If you want to improve your building set fish them out at xmass. For a free set is fine to have a building set, specially lots of people getting a free weapon set with it if you didnt buy the nugget version. I think is totally fine as it is. Lets not start to kill sets off after 1year

Set1, is straight into rubbish,only usefull on the new worlds.The only reason of this set that probably a propa drop set comes at day of the dead event.

Set2, Still no one needs it. I guess there is something else has to be in the event.

Set3, Interesting move, I am actually fine with the tactics going to dodging. What makes absolutely no sense that the set which you use from strength built gives more HP then the one you use from dexterity. The clothes on this gives 225health points the guardian gives 388healthpoints.
 
I think is time to reduce the set number on event. Free set and max 2 more is more than enough on the main events (easter,indepent,octoberfest) then we dont need this kind of no use for anything sets like set 1.
 
interpunk said:
I think is time to reduce the set number on event. Free set and max 2 more is more than enough on the main events (easter,indepent,octoberfest) then we dont need this kind of no use for anything sets like set 1.
Click to expand...
How would this help ? Its not like the probability of having 1 of the sets be utter trash on some event would be gone lol
 
ss68 said:
How would this help ? Its not like the probability of having 1 of the sets be utter trash on some event would be gone lol
Click to expand...
The reason there are trash sets because they have a number of slots per year lets say 20, and the avg lifespawn of a set seems to be atleast 2 years.The overal number mainstream sets about 16 which ony changes every two years, so for the slot of 20 you have 8 sets/year which are popular, then you can make some less popular like davis tutt, aponi, 49er ,oakley which is still useful for some, but useless for most and then you still got lets say 4-5 slot per year where utter rubish is placed. So reducing the yearly set numbers with some, should reduce the utter rubbish which they forced to come out with simply because of the lifespawn of the popular sets.
 
you are really committed to being stupid

church set for free, when it should be a main set, because god forbid you release a nugget church ride when the last one is paden tolbert from easter 2022, also with adventure bonus, players who want to play adventures will adventure with their main adventure set, it makes no sense to join an adventure with a weaker adventure set, unless you specifically see you are going to play against people so under leveled that the lower stats dont risk the win

set 1 is still completely useless except the belt and maybe the hat

the speed set is another one that doesnt make any sense, in 2024 we had therese nugget ride set, in 2025 we had masterson nugget ride set, now we are on a new speed ride set every oktoberfest :lol: when the actual clothes and weapons are only 1% faster, gonna transform 3 minutes walk into 2 minutes 58 seconds walk wow so good its insane (sarcasm), instead of i dont know releasing speed set as free set of day of the dead which is when new worlds actually start

and then comes the thing that we do need yes but you wont kill paden tolbert's nugget ride set from easter 2022, but killing the male oktoberfest nugget ride set from oktoberfest 2023 thats fine already? as always with you 0 logic

my advice is, as every player has said, fully change the sets (church + products + shooting/toughness), but it looks like you dont want to be logic and change them so then at least do this:

free set: IMPORTANT, give it as many flat labor points towards construction as possible

i would say turn set 1 into a full products set but literally every player has said that so i guess you have some reason to not do it (maybe you planned products for dotd?)

set 3: IMPORTANT, this set cant give as much hp as guarding bandit, as a matter of fact no duel set should ever give as much hp as guarding bandit ever again, it cant give more than 1 hp per level TOTAL, in exchange it can have a bit more tactics/shooting/aiming/dodging than guarding bandit
 
@Loki
We will need a "dislike" button for this event when it launches.
It's not fair to only have a "like" button; most people didn't like it, so please provide a "dislike" button that we can click.

Note: I'm sure the dislike button will be clicked more than the like button, PLEASE PROVIDE ONE

Maybe the worst event of the year.
 
BigNoob said:
you are really committed to being stupid

church set for free, when it should be a main set, because god forbid you release a nugget church ride when the last one is paden tolbert from easter 2022, also with adventure bonus, players who want to play adventures will adventure with their main adventure set, it makes no sense to join an adventure with a weaker adventure set, unless you specifically see you are going to play against people so under leveled that the lower stats dont risk the win

set 1 is still completely useless except the belt and maybe the hat

the speed set is another one that doesnt make any sense, in 2024 we had therese nugget ride set, in 2025 we had masterson nugget ride set, now we are on a new speed ride set every oktoberfest :lol: when the actual clothes and weapons are only 1% faster, gonna transform 3 minutes walk into 2 minutes 58 seconds walk wow so good its insane (sarcasm), instead of i dont know releasing speed set as free set of day of the dead which is when new worlds actually start

and then comes the thing that we do need yes but you wont kill paden tolbert's nugget ride set from easter 2022, but killing the male oktoberfest nugget ride set from oktoberfest 2023 thats fine already? as always with you 0 logic

my advice is, as every player has said, fully change the sets (church + products + shooting/toughness), but it looks like you dont want to be logic and change them so then at least do this:

free set: IMPORTANT, give it as many flat labor points towards construction as possible

i would say turn set 1 into a full products set but literally every player has said that so i guess you have some reason to not do it (maybe you planned products for dotd?)

set 3: IMPORTANT, this set cant give as much hp as guarding bandit, as a matter of fact no duel set should ever give as much hp as guarding bandit ever again, it cant give more than 1 hp per level TOTAL, in exchange it can have a bit more tactics/shooting/aiming/dodging than guarding bandit
Click to expand...
literally i said it, for the 4th time in that post.


problems that free set can bring: last free building set is red death from easter 2024... not to mention people with upgraded austin will keep using it, so that free set is skipable, not to mention last auctionable building weapon being mictecacihuatl, and also last nugget ride set is paden tolbert one from 2022, which do not sell anymore

problems that set 1 can bring: completely skipable garbage $H!t, only belt and perhaps hat seems to be usefull at all... i can only imagine the ride set being worse than a lost indian heavily upgraded xD

problems that set 2 can bring: last free ride set was hans steyrer in okto 2023, some people still use it, since they dont fill that much advantage swap to therese or bat masterson, not to mention that these 2 sets also have nugget ride set, which bring a new option will only make people not buying these old ones = InnoGames making less money

problems that set 3 can bring: since 2023 we hadnt set with tactics and dodging, and thats the 3rd only in 2026, not to mention that probably its ride set will be in sale aswell as the male oktober, and as far as it seems, that set is very similar to guarding but with shooting instead, so i can only imagine that its ride set will be exactly same as guarding, which isnt that better than male... so some people will be whilling in which to buy? male oktober or that new set 3 one? not to mention that the weapon is extremely similar to guarding bandit, which makes no sense at all... people will keep investing in male oktober weapon a lot, since they have more dodging and tactics...


free set solution: swap with set 2 and remove its attack/defense (no one cares to it), and make a better ride set to be purchasable with nuggets (similar as austin weapon).

set 1 solution: make it a full luck and drop chance set, better than fortune teller.

set 2 solution: swap it with free set, this would make some people still buy the therese or bat masterson ride set, aswell as the new building one, and some old users that still use hans steyrer to swap to it.

set 3 solution: hold it till next independence event, to sell its weapons with nugget, to also have finaly a ride set to be auctionable with tactics and dodging (last was john marshall from 2020), and bring something new to be in that oktoberfest set 3, like an new American Patriot with nugget ride set, we never had that before.

@Loki @ChickenMcGuy
 

Free set​

  • An interesting combination for church construction and adventures.
  • The clothing is better than lvl 0 Austin, while the Horseback Riding bonus is worse.
  • For adventures, the ride att/def bonus is a good alternative to the mounts from the previous event.
  • If the set is meant to remain free, I would personally slightly weaken the clothing and improve the ride bonus. I don't like idea of free set being metas, collecting event currency should be motivational.

Set 1​

  • The set is only really good for a few jobs, the most interesting one being summoning rain by dancing.
  • The main combination is Improved Product Drop Chance + Improved Luck. The set is essentially an upgraded version of the three-year-old Legba set in terms of bonuses. (so pretty useless)
  • The weapons are basically similar, and their bonuses are even less interesting than those of the clothing. It reminds me a lot of F. Waite's set.

Set 2​

  • The set is very good at what it is supposed to do, so I have no objections here.
  • It is the new meta for moving around the map quickly.
  • It might also provide some work points for the Bandit Leader.

Set 3​

  • Overall, it feels like an upgraded version of the 2023 Men's Oktoberfest set.
  • The bonuses are uninteresting, but fairly standard.
  • The weapons have the same damage as the sets from last year's Day of the Dead event, so that seems fine.
Apart from the Free set clothing and Set 2 for speed, where the current metas are already good enough, I find this event somehow boring.
I would probably remove the XP and money bonuses from Set 1 and instead boost the Luck + Product Drop Chance combination so that it could be competitive as well. I would also make the skill combination more appealing, or perhaps swap the Free set's church-building concept with Set 1.
 
(ignoring winner event sets and western friday sets)
best ride sets for dodging + tactics:

1º male okto (2023) not auctionable
2º guarding bandit (2026) not auctionable
3º bandit in love (2026) not auctionable
4º john marshall (2020) auctionable
5º johnny behan (2021) not auctionable
6º mclauglhlin (2019) auctionable
7º sarah astor (2022) not auctionable
2 out of 7 rides are auctionable
best weapons for dodging + tactics

1º male okto (2023) auctionable
2º 18th birthday (2026) not auctionable
3º guarding bandit (2026) auctionable
4º thomas (2021) auctionable
5º behan (2021) auctionable
6º bandit in love not auctionable
7º lucky clover auctionable
5 out of 7 weapon are auctionable
their plan with the new set 3

ride: 2º or 3º not auctionable
weapon: 2º or 3º auctionable
2 out of 8 tactics+dodge rides are auctionable
6 out of 8 tactics+dodge weapon are auctionable
best ride sets for building

1º Austin (2025) auctionable
2º Paden Tolbert (2022) not auctionable
3º Mictecacihuatl (2023) auctionable
4º Cortez (2020) auctionable
5º Patrick Henry (2023) not auctionable
6º Red Death (2024) not auctionable
7º Frida (2021) not auctionable
3 out of 7 ride are auctionable

best weapons for building

1º Austin (2025) not auctionable
2º Mictecacihuatl (2023) auctionable
3º Patrick Henry (2023) not auctionable
4º Paden Tolbert (2022) auctionable
5º Red Death (2024) not auctionable
6º Frida (2021) not auctionable
7º Cortez (2020) auctionable
3 out of 7 weapon are auctionable
their plan with the new set 3

1º austin 1^
2º new set free
3º austin 0^
3 out of 8 building ride are auctionable
3 out of 8 building weapon are auctionable
 
Test acc said:
problems that free set can bring: last free building set is red death from easter 2024... not to mention people with upgraded austin will keep using it, so that free set is skipable, not to mention last auctionable building weapon being mictecacihuatl, and also last nugget ride set is paden tolbert one from 2022, which do not sell anymore

problems that set 1 can bring: completely skipable garbage $H!t, only belt and perhaps hat seems to be usefull at all... i can only imagine the ride set being worse than a lost indian heavily upgraded xD

problems that set 2 can bring: last free ride set was hans steyrer in okto 2023, some people still use it, since they dont fill that much advantage swap to therese or bat masterson, not to mention that these 2 sets also have nugget ride set, which bring a new option will only make people not buying these old ones = InnoGames making less money

problems that set 3 can bring: since 2023 we hadnt set with tactics and dodging, and thats the 3rd only in 2026, not to mention that probably its ride set will be in sale aswell as the male oktober, and as far as it seems, that set is very similar to guarding but with shooting instead, so i can only imagine that its ride set will be exactly same as guarding, which isnt that better than male... so some people will be whilling in which to buy? male oktober or that new set 3 one? not to mention that the weapon is extremely similar to guarding bandit, which makes no sense at all... people will keep investing in male oktober weapon a lot, since they have more dodging and tactics...
Click to expand...
Free set: It's fine the way it is, free sets are not supposed to be OP, they are free, for everyone, mainly for new players, new worlds and low lvl/money players.
1st set: It's a filler set, it's fine, not every set should be BIS. The belt is great.
2nd set: It's a good speed set, the premium horse sets in the past were trash, maybe this one will be better.
3rd set: They are out of ideal probably, but the changes they made are good, right now, this set is not just a range counterpart uninspired copy of the Guarding bandit, it's different. Less tactics, more dodging. The weapons are still too similar in my opinion.
 
@innogames @Loki @ChickenMcGuy
Are you going to listen to us, or are we just talking nonsense?

I thought you wanted feedback to listen to us, but you're just making things up

Next time, release the sets without asking for feedback; it'll be less embarrassing, and don't make us waste our time trying to improve
 
Test acc said:
(ignoring winner event sets and western friday sets)
best ride sets for dodging + tactics:


6º mclauglhlin (2019) auctionable
7º sarah astor (2022) not auctionable
2 out of 7 rides are auctionable


best weapons for building

1º Austin (2025) not auctionable
2º Mictecacihuatl (2023) auctionable
3º Patrick Henry (2023) not auctionable
4º Paden Tolbert (2022) auctionable
5º Red Death (2024) not auctionable
6º Frida (2021) not auctionable
7º Cortez (2020) auctionable
3 out of 7 weapon are auctionable
their plan with the new set 3

1º austin 1^
2º new set free
3º austin 0^
3 out of 8 building ride are auctionable
3 out of 8 building weapon are auctionable
Click to expand...
Some small corrections:

6º mclauglhlin (2019) auctionable
7º Polly Cooper not sarah astor auctionable
3 out of 7 rides are auctionable

best weapons for building
1º Austin (2025) not auctionable
2º Mictecacihuatl (2023) auctionable
3º Red Death (2024) not auctionable
4º Patrick Henry (2023) not auctionable
5º Paden Tolbert (2022) auctionable
6º Frida (2021) not auctionable
7º Cortez (2020) auctionable
3 out of 7 weapons are auctionable
 
WhyN0t said:
Free set: It's fine the way it is, free sets are not supposed to be OP, they are free, for everyone, mainly for new players, new worlds and low lvl/money players.
1st set: It's a filler set, it's fine, not every set should be BIS. The belt is great.
2nd set: It's a good speed set, the premium horse sets in the past were trash, maybe this one will be better.
3rd set: They are out of ideal probably, but the changes they made are good, right now, this set is not just a range counterpart uninspired copy of the Guarding bandit, it's different. Less tactics, more dodging. The weapons are still too similar in my opinion.
Click to expand...
free sets need to be op, to people during event notskip it, to people that dont got it have no way to optain anymore, they arent upgradeable, and not auctionable so they actualy need to be OP... Nat, bandit in love, nodin and even blue thunder people still use, meanwhile... unknown bandit, james, cornelia i know people that have never have wear these sets.

set 1: will come skipable if keeps that way

set 2: the problem is that they would still sell these old rides, i would agree to keep this way if wouldnt have bat masterson or therese to sell again, and last free speed set is hans from 2023, so make more sense that be the free set of this year, and some are still using hans to its days.

set 3: same problem as set 2, its ride set will sell aswell as male oktober, meanwhile weapon is same as guarding bantid, which is not that better than male okto weapon, no sense at all bring that set in this event, its better hold it to next year's independence and make a better weapon than male okto (without vigor/shooting) with an auctionable ride set WHICH LAST ONE WAS john marshall in god damn 2020
 
WesternCalin said:
Some small corrections:

6º mclauglhlin (2019) auctionable
7º Polly Cooper not sarah astor auctionable
3 out of 7 rides are auctionable

best weapons for building
1º Austin (2025) not auctionable
2º Mictecacihuatl (2023) auctionable
3º Red Death (2024) not auctionable
4º Patrick Henry (2023) not auctionable
5º Paden Tolbert (2022) auctionable
6º Frida (2021) not auctionable
7º Cortez (2020) auctionable
3 out of 7 weapons are auctionable
Click to expand...
thanks for correcting the bulding weapon (polly i kept out the rank because i hate it so much, sarah has exact same tact and dodge actualy but who cares, both trash)
 
The chances of another change are pretty slim. The event should start this week on beta (tomorrow or Wednesday) and next week on other markets.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top