if thats true then its horrible, thats the problem with them, they either make something way too OP or completely useless trash no in between no balanced stuff
For example: the best xp craftable that we can craft without cooldown is the cocktail that gives 20% xp, they either gonna listen to emma and buff it to 50% which is way too OP or they gonna keep it at 15% and let it be useless, instead of setting for a 25% or 30% that would make sense
dont waste your time announcing those 4 new buffs I can guarantee you that no one is gonna like any of them, instead restart from 0, make 4 new buffs that are SLIGHTLY better than what we have
ideas inspired on what you did:
25 or 30% xp, give it to blacksmiths as cooks already have plenty of xp buffs in their craft
50% duel motivation, 50% energy, give it to cooks, its not too OP for clicking due to no work motivation
+7 attack +80-95 dmg, i think its great time to have a "craftable rice stew", viewfinder/booby trap used to be BiS and they were not in the UP shop, lets go back to that time again, for tonics that do not have FF buffs yet, allows for smiths to keep booby traps for tanks
forget everything that has duel damage, if people want duel damage we have toy guns which give 100-150, way too OP, and in the 30-45 range we have polishing stones, come up with a completely different buff