Holiday Set 2025 - Feedback

[WhyN0t]

Update:

I would have bought and upgraded the set even without the buff, but now it's OP, it's a must have. I was going to buy 12k nuggets to upgrade to the new Western Friday set to use it as an all rounder, but it doesn't make sense anymore when there's a set as good as this for luck/money. Thanks InnoGames for saving me some real money
The power creep is so exaggerated that it's no longer justified to spend real money in the game. I don't really understand what InnoGames wants to achieve, but I can't say it bothers me

 

[WesternCalin]

I would have bought and upgraded the set even without the buff, but now it's OP, it's a must have. I was going to buy 12k nuggets to upgrade to the new Western Friday set to use it as an all rounder, but it doesn't make sense anymore when there's a set as good as this for luck/money. Thanks InnoGames for saving me some real money
The power creep is so exaggerated that it's no longer justified to spend real money in the game. I don't really understand what InnoGames wants to achieve, but I can't say it bothers me

@BaggyBlue Just read this comment and you will understand that now this set is better than everything we have on right now including best nugget sets. That's not how you are going forward with making sets better than previous ones. A 5-10% increase is fine but this is atleast a 25% increase if not more.

 

[BaggyBlue]

@BaggyBlue Just read this comment and you will understand that now this set is better than everything we have on right now including best nugget sets. That's not how you are going forward with making sets better than previous ones. A 5-10% increase is fine but this is atleast a 25% increase if not more.

Yes, so what! As has been written here many times! You can't please everyone in The West beta and worlds!

PS: You replied to someone else! How cute/sweet that is.

 

[BaggyBlue]

You all know! It's hilarious in the forum on the Tee-West-Welten website! So many people are writing! It's 2025, not 2015 anymore! And InnoGame is finally making an effort! And then there are those who say it's too much of a good thing! Are you finally happy with what InnoGame is doing? Or will it continue like this next year? InnoGame isn't sleeping, it's 2026 and they're still beginners! I bet that next year, 2026, will be just as bad.

You're forgetting everything! @Loki passes on our feedback! Including my comments! Don't forget, if you tell InnoGame's leading community managers that you're not satisfied with what we're giving them, then we'll do what we like, whether they like it or not! Never forget, all feedback is passed on to InnoGame! Period.

 

[WesternCalin]

Why you think is that? Feedback is sent only if it makes sense, none of your comments are feedback, you are just attacking me. And to explain you more about the set: Emma made a suggestion to buff it but they took only half of her feedback and put it on their initial set thus making it stronger than Emma suggested. At lvl 250 their initial value was 214% Luck/114% Money, Emma suggested 210% Luck/210% Money and they buffed it to 234% Luck/234%Money and my first suggestion was 214% Luck/144% Money and then 210% Luck/150% Money.

 

[BaggyBlue]

I'm happy for a bit more luck! I'm still looking for a few recipes! And with Buf's plum cake offering a +75% chance of luck, I have even more opportunities, and then there's the bonus weekend, so maybe I'll have even better luck!

 

[I AM INEVITABLE]

I would have bought and upgraded the set even without the buff, but now it's OP, it's a must have. I was going to buy 12k nuggets to upgrade to the new Western Friday set to use it as an all rounder, but it doesn't make sense anymore when there's a set as good as this for luck/money. Thanks InnoGames for saving me some real money
The power creep is so exaggerated that it's no longer justified to spend real money in the game. I don't really understand what InnoGames wants to achieve, but I can't say it bothers me

You are the last person here who needs to talk about power creep. Begging them to nerf the shop items and here we are now trying to fix the unfixable.

 

[Uchiha Madara]

Honestly, I think this set is way too overpowered right now, and that’s coming from a level 200+ player. Don’t get me wrong, I don’t mind high bonuses...it actually benefits me since I’ll get massive money and luck boosts. But still, it’s just too strong.


If they release this set with these bonuses, we probably won’t see another money/luck set for at least 3 years. And even when a new one does come out, it definitely won’t be as powerful as this, not even close. Of course, some players will complain and demand something like 350% money and luck, but realistically, anyone wanting a stronger set will have to wait a few to several years.


I would personally nerf the bonuses slightly...maybe drop them from 120% to 100%, or keep money at 120% but lower luck to 80%. The individual items are fine as they are, and the animal, yield, and weapon bonuses all seem balanced too.

 

[Emma Swan]

You can still create better money/luck set with nugget/sale items. I dont see nothing wrong with being this set better 20% than Gibson. We are almost 3 years past Her. By higher bonus per set you will be able to use this set in combinations with other items. Or its too weak, or too strong, or this not good or that, now they finally listened. Just let folks enjoy at least one good set per year without causing drama and beying pain in the ...

Also, some of you should start with understanding that we are heading into 2026, which means 2022 are going to be free dropping in hunting events and you need a difference between these sets and sets that we are heading into. Oherwise players can stick to old ones and ignore new ones that are more expensive and more difficult to obtain and upgrade. And dont forget 2024 was a big jump in sets, so dont get heartattack when 2027 sets are going to be something else.

Also, Be prepared not to see another good money/luck set for 2 maybe 3 years. So dont ask to nerf it. There is a reason for that set.

 

[I AM INEVITABLE]

Whats the point of nerf? So we can get every year a set that is 5% stronger? Its a pve set. Yes better give this drrong now and give the next sfter 3 years. Helen gibson was op when it came out remember. I rather have broken luck and cash sets than these madness with duelling and fort fighting.

 

[Miss Florida]

The set stats look great, well done Loki!

 

[BaggyBlue]

You can still create better money/luck set with nugget/sale items. I dont see nothing wrong with being this set better 20% than Gibson. We are almost 3 years past Her. By higher bonus per set you will be able to use this set in combinations with other items. Or its too weak, or too strong, or this not good or that, now they finally listened. Just let folks enjoy at least one good set per year without causing drama and beying pain in the ...

Also, some of you should start with understanding that we are heading into 2026, which means 2022 are going to be free dropping in hunting events and you need a difference between these sets and sets that we are heading into. Oherwise players can stick to old ones and ignore new ones that are more expensive and more difficult to obtain and upgrade. And dont forget 2024 was a big jump in sets, so dont get heartattack when 2027 sets are going to be something else.

Also, Be prepared not to see another good money/luck set for 2 maybe 3 years. So dont ask to nerf it. There is a reason for that set.

 

[Uchiha Madara]

I dont see nothing wrong with being this set better 20% than Gibson

its 20% better at 150. After that the higher you are the more stronger it is and if you also upgrade individual items you can get it to be even stronger. So in total it can be 50% better.

Whats the point of nerf? So we can get every year a set that is 5% stronger? Its a pve set

A set that is fixed 10-15% stronger should be fine. 5% is still fine too. 50% is not fine, its OP and it can create very big inflation. So what if its PVE? Then we should ask for the next drop set to have 500% bonuses? Gibson even 3 years old is WAY TO GOOD. You get tons of cash from farming, and even that, you dont really use a full money set as it is to farm cash, you use items from multiple sets together to create a set for money and with these individual items you can reach 500% money bonus easily without any sweat. My current money set is at 423% using, if I change Cornilias belt, hat and Summer sandals and wear the new items I will have around 505%. I already farm 850-900 dollars per 15s, whats the difference if I farm 100 dollars more?

Like I said before, I personally dont mind if the bonuses are so high, it actually benefits me, but I will have to speak the truth and say that this set is now OP.
Also lots of you seem to forget that Cornelia which was a free set is better than Gibson

 

[BaggyBlue]

Can it be refined or not? If it's a Nugget Purchase Set, can it not be refined, and does the value increase with the level?

 

[Uchiha Madara]

Can it be refined or not? If it's a Nugget Purchase Set, can it not be refined, and does the value increase with the level?

Its a Holiday set so yes it will be able to be upgraded and of course since the individual items give bonus per level then yes the value will increase even higher.

 

[BaggyBlue]

@WesternCalin Look, this is what I want to explain! You give good information without shouting! I could discuss things better; you have such good suggestions and arguments! What I said is what I wanted to drill into you!

 

[BaggyBlue]

Its a Holiday set so yes it will be able to be upgraded and of course since the individual items give bonus per level then yes the value will increase even higher.

Oh cool, thanks for the info!

 

[WhyN0t]

You are the last person here who needs to talk about power creep. Begging them to nerf the shop items and here we are now trying to fix the unfixable.

What are you talking about?

 

[WesternCalin]

@WesternCalin Look, this is what I want to explain! You give good information without shouting! I could discuss things better; you have such good suggestions and arguments! What I said is what I wanted to drill into you!

It doesnt bother me if people attack me. That's why i showed you someone else's perspective so you can see it from another angle than mine but like people are saying here this set is too OP and to Emma we will for sure get another Luck/Money set next year. This year alone we had 3 of them, 2024 we also had 2. The fact that Helen is still a viable set after 3 years and we get a new Helen which is 40% better it's pure madness. Stats are creeping up so much that you will ask for all sets to be 40% better than previous ones and you will never be able to use any set other then the newest one.

 

[WesternCalin]

To remind you this set is absolutely Free, Auctionable and Upgradable and is 40% better than the previous one where as Full Nugget sets barely reach that % increase.